of the stories made a significant impression, while others I didn't connect with, The parts of Carver's prose I am trying to understand were not elucidated by this prose, and so while I enjoyed BAM's stories, I didn't learn what I was hoping to learn from them being a new way to approach dirty realism.
My personal favorite story in this collection is "Offerings," which originally appeared in The New Yorker in thes, "Offerings" is not "flash" but it is very small for a traditional short story length, I am guessing maybe underwords, I can't get over the story's magic, I keep rereadin
g it to comprehend its hypnotic complexity and simplicity both its honesty and intuitive sense of how the world leaves us so connected and so alone.
The others in this award winning collection the collection won the PEN/Hemingway Award have this quality also, the title story "Shiloh" is breathtaking.
Jesus, they all are. Some of them are also outrageously funny,
It never stops with this writer's work, her novels and stories, BAM's work bubbles with longing, sly humor, a dangerous amount of tenderness, sadness, and everyday wisdom She does this the way no other writer does, in such an accessible, intuitive, nononsense way, using tiny and sometimes random details which stick in ones mind forever.
. .
Almost everyone whose writing I respect has something similar to say about Bobbie Ann Mason's work, Mostly, when I bring her work up, good writers say to me "She is the one who made me want to write, or think I could write.
" BAM creates for the reader a lingering, unforgettable ache for the feeling ones of this world, I am so overdue on reviewing this bookI read it weeks ago and life got in the way, Mason wrote this book in the earlys and the only reason I picked it up was the author has the same name as I do.
Silly, right
This book of short stories was VERY well written but each story had a similar themewomen living in western Kentucky or from western Kentucky as in two of the stories who were restless and unhappy in their marriages.
“Mork amp Mindy” was mentioned several times as a popular show, It was very strangeI didnt have to read the whole book to get a good taste of how well Bobbie Ann Mason writes, though.
I just wish the stories had a bit more variety, So the writing was abut the story “plots” were more likes, I am going to shy away from short story collections for a while, I'm not a fan of Mason's writing style, nor am I a fan of her choices in subject matter, Her characters felt dull and lifeless, and her writing made it feel as if I was watching a puppet being strung from one paragraph to another.
I must have read
this inoror so, and I remember never having heard of her before and then being very pleasantly surprised, liking these stories a lot.
Enough for me to buy one or two also buy her collection Love Life at least, since that's also on my shelf,
And having just now, almostyears on, reread the opening story I don't think I've changed my opinion, It's simply a very well done short story, Typical New Yorker story, maybe, in so far as they can be typical, Anyway, I know I probably won't be disappointed if I take this or Love Life of the shelf again to give it a reread.
I only read the short story Shiloh,
I couldn't really see the point or the purpose of the story, . . :/ "Bobbie Ann Mason is an unusually attractive younger writer whose works have appeared in The New Yorker, . . " Isn't it strange that the above is the first sentence of the inside book jacket cover for this book The book won many awards.
Do any of Philip Roth's book jackets include statements like "Philip Roth is really handsome" Strange,
The stories are terrific, I just don't see how writers master the short story and then go on to write multiple great short stories, Bobbie Ann Mason creates funny, poignant, thoughtful stories out of ordinary people and mundane situations, What a great imagination she has, accompanied by an amazing facility with the language, The title story is as good as advertised, but after that I found this collection relentlessly onenote, Almost every story features a vaguely disillusioned heroine, a poorlydeveloped husband who's not on the scene, and a rural setting sketched with the same tired references to daytime television and hamburger noodle casseroles.
It bored me.
Collection of short stories Women's view mostly about breaking up of relationships, takes place in the south, These were really something. Not too much of a weak one in the lot, My current favorite: Georgeann, the malcontent preachers wife, happy with her lousy chickens and playing Space Invaders in the basement, Sorry, not Space Invaders. The Galaxians. Space Invaders is the better game, says the trucker, because things come at you headon,
And then theres Mary and her dentist in “Residents and Transients,” and Nancy Culpupper twice over, and and
How Id describe these stories, actually: if the gentler Larry Brown think A Miracle of Catfish all the Sam parts of Fay wrote DriveBy Truckers songs.
The incongruities, secrets, and hidden depths in people, heres a book full of them, Verhalen die me hebben geraakt, Ze spelen alle in Kentucky en brengen mannen en vrouwen in beeld die ondanks tegenslagen of beperkte mogelijkheden zich door het leven ploeteren.
Het zijn net kleine documentaires, Een vrouw schildert alleen maar meloenen en hoopt dat een verzamelaar ze zal kopen, een man rijdt dagelijks de bus die gehandicapten van en naar school brent, een vrouw die een borstamputatie heeft ondergaan hoort dat haar pas verworven vriend in de gevangenis zit.
De personen hebben vaak te maken met armoede en hebben vaak weinig bestendige relaties, Rafelige levens die door Mason met liefde en precisie worden opgetekend, En: altijd met een open eind, Fantastisch! I read this collection of stories in college for a Southern Literature class my senior year, I loved it then, and rereading it now, I still love it, but its definitely more poignant and less funny as I recall it, but its still very good.
The stories here, and theres a lot of them for a short collection involve marriages and families living mostly in and around Kentucky in thes.
These marriages are often strained or have taken on a kind of weight that wasnt present in their origin and the new form is being questioned by at least one usually the wife of the people in them.
In the opening story, “Shiloh” the marriage turns into a kind of showdown as the wife, now starting to lift weights as a kind of unconscious escape plan, is dealing with a husband ostensibly on disability, but a husband that has decided no longer to work.
As a way to “recharge” their marriage the mother in law insists on a trip to the Shiloh battlefield in Tennessee because its a place she has always wanted to visit.
And that kind of forced enjoyment of someone else desires is perfect little gem of what an unfulfilling marriage might look like, And so the trip happens,
In other stories, a woman cradles the secret of a growing tumor in her body from the people around her as a kind of extension of herself shes not yet ready to allow others in on.
In another, a woman has brought an outsider a nonKentuckian to a holiday dinner that is fueled entirely on whiskey it seems.
In another, the dog the husband brought to the marriage is on his last legs literally, though, hes not even on his legs because the story is titled “Lying Doggo” and Nancy Culpepper who is the protagonist of two stories here and several more from Bobbie Ann Mason later worries that despite their having a kid together, the dogs impending death will end their marriage.
Its a very good collection that reads so good together and feelss in the best of ways,
Photo: sitelink research. uky. edu/odyssey/s . Shiloh and other stories by Bobbie Ann Mason
I didnt enjoy this as much as Feathered Crowns, The stories felt dated but not historical, I also have a great deal of trouble relating to the characters, most of whom dont seem to make decision as much as drift.
I am probably too urban for this, I also want more plot, fewer disillusioned wives, and more oomph, Blahed me out.
Possibly probably my favorite short story collection ever, When this book first appeared, in, Bobbie Ann Masons voice and viewpoint felt so singular and vibrantly odd, I almost wanted to move to Kentucky to see what was going on down there.
Except for the complete and absolute Americanness of her characters, Mason might have dropped into American literature from another planet,
Weirdly, I read her short novel, In Country, and found it sort of meh I should probably try it again, And I know I purchased her subsequent story collection, Love Life, but I dont know that I ever even cracked its spine, It felt like Shiloh and Other Stories was enough all on its own,
Rereading it now, I was pleasantly surprised at how well so many of the stories have held up, and the additional burnish many of them have taken on with an additional forty years almost under my belt.
The collection feels very much like a novel in many ways, immersive and soulfilling, I felt the same way recently about the movie version of Nomadland, a cinematic and spiritual journey through a lost or diminishing America that would be instantly recognizable to any of Masons characters.
That theme of loss and diminishment is a strumming throughline here, The lead character in the title story says, “I have this crazy feeling I missed something, ” In the very next story, a wife senses her husband is “trying to put together the years of their marriage into a convincing whole and this was as far as he got,” while the husband himself thinks that “having a daughter in college makes him feel he has missed something.
” Time and again, Masons characters look back at an American Dream that was never quite real for them and think, “Ive about decided theres no use trying to hang on to anything.
You just lose it all in the end, You might as well just not care, ”
But of course they do care, They care about knickknacks, and homecanned food, and sewing, and TV shows like Charlies Angels or Mork amp Mindy, They desire, they want, although even they are often not clear what it is theyre seeking, Just something.
The women in Shiloh and Other Stories desire most of all, and this almost always mystifies the men in their lives.
One man, in his own wedding picture, “seems bewildered, as if he did not know what to expect, marrying a woman who has her eyes fixed on something so far away.
” And, back in the title story, Leroy is left behind on the eponymous battlefield while “Norma Jean has reached the bluff, and she is looking out over the Tennessee River.
Now she turns toward Leroy and waves her arms, Is she beckoning him She seems to be doing an exercise for her chest muscles, ” In the final story, following a radical mastectomy, Ruby “has learned to extend her right arm and raise it slightly, Next, the doctors have told her, she will gradually reach higher and higher an idea that thrills her, as though there were something tangible above her to reach for.
”
In my favorite story in the collection, “A New Wave Format,” its actually a man who suddenly finds himself desiring and reaching for something more.
Early on, Edwin “still feels like the same person, unchanged, that he was twenty years ago, ” But later, despite the nagging sense that his much younger girlfriend is not right for him or maybe because of it, Edwin declares, “I was never serious before in my life.
Im just now, at this point in my life this week getting to be serious, ” Perhaps because this story centers on a man, it ends with an ambiguous but distinctly foreboding hint of violence another aspect of the crumbling American Dream.
“The twentieth centurys taking all the mysteries out of life,” a character says at one point, I cant help but wonder how the same character how any of these characters would feel about life now that weve crossed into the twentyfirst.
Fantastic book.
.
Gain Access Shiloh And Other Stories Articulated By Bobbie Ann Mason Offered As Multimedia Format
Bobbie Ann Mason