liked this book,plus pages , Guv especially the insights into the Pickwick characters and nineteenth century Holborn landmarks, the side stories and all round Pickwickmania of, London.
The sad tale of Charles Whitehead, afforded an early chance to pen Pickwick, who dies penniless in Melbourne Australia, is compelling and the tale of Dickens' favourite clown Grimaldi and even sadder death of Grimaldi's drunken son is a key theme in the book.
Drink, wasted talent, poverty, petty squabbles, opportunism and death haunt the book and each episode of backalley dealings and literary and sporting obsessions ring true and while I admire the story greatly and respect how the tale is woven through so many characters, the book at times lacks the whimsical esprit and comic potency of Dickens' writing and also does not quite have you side with cast off artist Robert Seymour, in the way that you might perhaps side with Nancy, Little Nell, Oliver Twist and certainly Samuel Pickwick himself.
Whom may have come up with the original idea for Pickwick is the overriding theme and the book goes to great lengths to prove that cartoonist Robert Seymour came up with the character for Pickwick, the sports theme and brilliant sketches such as 'the sagacious dog'.
This may well be the case but as has been proven by so many memorable characters written in intervening years, characters such as the 'young un', Smike, Sikes, Fagin, Pegotty, Ralph Nickleby, Mrs Faversham, Pip, Madame Lefarge, Uriah Heep, Dickens had it in him to write for his time and to write characters that walked off the page and into our very mind's eye.
This is a special book in a different way, What Death and Mr Pickwick does is show in very telling detail how authors and writers come up with ideas and mold them into a format which will be appealing to the general public.
In the same way that Sketches by Boz attracted considerable interest, Death and Mr Pickwick is a very promising piece of historical fiction.
It is no Pickwick Papers but does a fine job of bringing attention to the genius of the parties involved in the creation of the work and also brings to light several fantastic stories about the period.
The story of the George and Vulture is one that Dickens would have kicked himself for not thinking to write.
What will Mr Jarvis come up with next As a Dickens fan, later in life, I thank Mr Jarvis for this and eagerly await his next book.
/This was fantastic. This novel is completely compelling, clever, witty, full of imagination and historical insight and above all, very, very Dickensian, I adored it from start to finish, It's a long novel, but well worthy of its length, If you're a Dickens fan, I highly recommend this,
There is a novel in here somewhere but atpages
"First catch your hare" begins the apocryphalthcentury recipe for jugged hare.
Author Stephen Jarvis not only shows the catching of the hare, but tells you how to make the jug as well, and set the fire no doubt.
There is certainly a novel here in the story of how Charles Dickens supposedly hijacked the ideas of his collaborator, illustrator Robert Seymour, in producing his first great success, The Pickwick Papers.
But do we have to hear the travails of the artist's father, and the history of every other cartoonist working at the beginning of theth century Does the mere mention of a street clown have to segue into apage history of the Grimaldi family And is it helpful to encase all this within a modernday story in which the novel is commissioned by an eccentric patron known as sic Mr.
Inbelicate Yes, Dickens himself wrote at great length, but his genius made his books hang together, Much as I was enlightened by Mr, Jarvis's information and enjoyed his writing style, I soon found myself resenting the sheer amount I had to read to get into his story.
Reading on, I began to understand that much of his method was to demonstrate that the ideas for Pickwickthe concept of preparing a series of illustrations as the framework for text, the idea of centering them around a rambunctious gentlemen's club, the names and nature of many of the characters, even the ideas for individual episodeswere already in Seymour's head before he met Dickens.
Those who have read The Pickwick Papers will recognize where many of these apparently random episodes are heading.
Without that knowledge, the first half of Jarvis's book will seem scattered and episodic, though often interesting, Dickens' own writing at this stage was much more episodic than in his later works, so you could say that Jarvis is merely prefiguring the manner of his model.
There is even a kind of fascination to this abundance it is a bit like reading a wellwritten encyclopedia, But an encyclopedia is not a novel although Jarvis will bring most of it to earth eventually, he buries his story in a blizzard of apparently arbitrary information tossed into the air and waiting to fall.
Charles Dickens is not mentioned by name until page, But he appears under his pseudonym of Boz beginning on page, and crops up once or twice before that as a youth known simply as Chatham Charlie.
As compared to the extensive buildup of the character of Robert Seymour, Dickens sneaks late into the story and simply grabs it.
The interactions between the illustrator and author of Pickwick occupy no more thanpages of thepage book.
And the key exchange takes place in a tenpage scene in which Boz Dickens treats his collaborator with a highhanded arrogance amounting virtually to professional assassination.
Nothing that Jarvis has shown us of Boz so far makes the excesses of this scene credible, nor does his long and detailed portrait of Seymour give much hint of how totally it would destroy him.
The ascent of one and demise of the other happen so quickly as to feel like a slap in the faceor stab in the gutwithin the leisurely pace of the rest.
With this stroke, Jarvis abandons the normal development of the novelist to give us a piece of violent polemic to make his particular point.
There are stillpages to go, but they feel like a hugely distended epilogue, We hear of the runaway success of Pickwick, which became the media sensation of its time, We hear of instances where models for one of other of the characters recognize themselves with either fury or pride.
We hear of the steps taken by Dickens' publishers and associates to distance him from claims that the inspiration was not his own.
And we read of the sad decline of the Seymour family, living under the shadow of theft and imputation of failure.
And so the story drags on into the twentieth century, as Dickens writes other books, is honored, and dies, and Pickwick mania eventually runs its course.
We even discover the real name of the annoyingly knowing Mr, Inbelicate. Not that it matters.
Had Stephen Jarvis simply entitled his book "Pickwick: a History," it might have been a nonfiction bestseller, It would have lost the color he brings to his imagined scenes and dialogues, but his vast erudition would all fall properly into place.
But as a novel, the book is an unwieldy hybrid that, for me, just doesn't work,
Actually no, Thinking this over, I realize that the case that Jarvis is making can only be advanced in fiction, When other reviewers say they were convinced, what were they convinced by A series of fictional encounters devised by the author to place Robert Seymour into situations that might seem to prefigure Pickwickbut we have only the author's word that they happened.
I see now that the purpose of the modern archivist character, Mr, Inbelicate, is to miraculously come up with "documents" without any compunction to attest to their source there is not a single footnote in the book itself, nor any endnote that might attempt to separate fact from fancy.
There is something fundamentally dishonest about using the trappings of history to argue a reallife case of such importance, but in fact using the meretricious tools of fiction.
I think any book that you read on the beach qualifies as a beach read, so why not anpage Dickensian novel about Dickens Wait is that meta Based on the story of The Pickwick Papers and the beginning of the career of Charles Dickens, this is a delightful novel, full of history and fun and its now in paperback! It will charm your pants off.
Tune in to our weekly podcast dedicated to all things new
books, All The Books: sitelink com/category/allthe A MASTERWORK OF A NOVEL
Stephen Jarvis has in Death and Mr, Pickwick created anpage masterwork of a novel incorporating an astronomical amount of research and history into an incredibly readable, thought provoking, touching, funny and exciting yes exciting piece of literature.
Multiple vignettes, each a gorgeous little fully fleshed nugget of story, are tied together so flawlessly to the main narrative of illustrator William Seymour, writer Charles Dickens and the origin, creating, publishing and reception of The Pickwick Papers, making an incredible reading experience.
I won't go into the plot of the book, I'm sure many people leaving reviews will do this.
And I'm sure there will be some controversy regarding the theories within, especially from die hard Dickens fans, Some may say it's too long, or overwritten, . . IT'S NOT! Don't let any of this steer you away from this amazing piece of work,
Thank you Mr, Jarvis for two weeks I'm a slow reader of Seymour, “Boz” and of course Pickwick and the rest of the Club! I hope you have a VERY long and prolific career.
.
Obtain Immediately Death And Mr. Pickwick Illustrated By Stephen Jarvis Shared As Electronic Format
Stephen Jarvis